Reward Yourself - Join Now

FAQ Shoes

Exchange Policy

  • The first exchange is on us. Please email us at and we will get you set up with a return label. Any additional exchanges will be paid by the customer.

    Shoes MUST be in unused, like new condition, with all the original packaging. If we receive your shoes in unsatisfactory condition, we will send the shoes back to you.

    If you are an International customer and wish to exchange your shoes, the customer will have to pay for shipping to our warehouse.

    No returns or exchanges on closeout shoes, One-Offs, or Blem shoes.

  • Yes. You may choose to go with a different model. Any models with a higher retail value will be honored. Any models with a lower retail value will get the difference reimbursed by store credit. 

  • Items MUST be returned in new condition. If items are not returned in orginal condition with original undamaged box and packaging, the shoes will be sent back to you.

  • No, we email a pre-paid shipping label when needed. This applies for first exchanges only on eligible items.

  • Once the shoes are received, please allow 2-3 business days to receive your new tracking number. 

  • Online orders must be returned to us with the return label provided.

  • Not if the shoes were ordered online directly. If ordered from a shop, please exchange them at the shop you ordered them from.


  • We have taken great strides to ensure our sizing chart is as accurate as possible. Please refer to the sizing chart for the model of shoe you are interested in for accurate So iLL shoe sizing.

  • All brands have a different take on their sizing (including different sizing within brands) Please refer to the sizing chart for the model of shoe you are interested in for accurate So iLL sizing.

  • Leather shoes can stretch: up to 1 full size

    Synthetic: tends to ebb and flow during a session. Synthetic will become more malleable as you wear them and then revert back to size when they are cold.

  • All of our synthetic models are Vegan friendly.

  • We proudly ship our shoes from our hometown warehouse in Saint Louis, Missouri